Epson Stylus Photo 1270 Delivers Large, Lasting Images

This Super B-size inkjet printer generates dazzling images that may last for as long as 25 years.
Written by Lori Grunin on June 9, 2000
Categories: Hardware, Printers, Reviews

Related Reading

Bright colors and tiny dots alone simply don't cut it anymore for high-quality inkjet printing. We're past the point where it just has to look good: It now has to look good and last. Epson's $499 Stylus Photo 1270 does both in spades. It also handles Super B-size print jobs, accommodating media as large as 13 by 19 inches.

With its 4-picoliter drops, the new printing system introduced in the 1270's product line offers the smallest ink droplets on the market, which the printer uses to full advantage by printing at up to 1,440 by 720 dpi. When combined with special Epson media -- Heavyweight Matte Paper and Premium Glossy Photo Paper (a resin-coated stock) -- the new ink formulation has been estimated to last as long as long as 25 and 10 years respectively (see editor's note below). This is significantly longer than the one to five years typical for most currently available desktop inkjets. Keep in mind that the 10- and 25-year figures are only estimates, however, based on tests run by the Wilhelm Imaging Research, and that these tests assume a museum-quality environment. In practice, there is simply no way to know how well these inks will hold up over time for real-world use. If you truly need archival quality, you'll have to switch from dye-based inks to pigment-based inks, such as those used by the $899 Epson Stylus Photo 2000p.

Thankfully, Epson hasn't sacrificed its hallmark industry-leading image-printing quality for longevity. In practice, the small drop size, 6-color photo inks (CMYKcm), and high resolution deliver prints with about the grain you'd expect from an 8-by-10-inch print made from a good ISO 100 35mm film. In both black-and-white and color images, the detail, contrast, and dynamic range lead the desktop-printer pack.

Beyond Performance
The Stylus Photo 1270 also serves up some welcome productivity features. The most important, of course, is speed: During testing, ten 4-by-6-inch images printed edge-to-edge on the glossy roll-feed paper at an average rate of 83 seconds per print. A full letter-sized image took about 4 minutes at a resolution of 720 dpi (regardless of scan resolution), and about twice as long at 1,440 dpi.

Epson's new ink-cartridge system adds some intelligence to the mix as well. You can now exchange cartridges midway through their print cycle without losing information about the amount of ink remaining. The ink cost per page ranges from about 11 cents (20-percent coverage) to 40 cents (80-percent coverage); archival paper cost varies from a low of 23 cents for a single letter-sized Matte page to $2.21 for a sheet of B-size Premium Glossy Photo paper. The roll-feed paper averages about $13.66, and can be used to print panoramas nearly 44 inches long.

Shades of Distinction
Color-matching across various media types and print resolutions proved relatively consistent -- as consistent as could be expected given the different paper surfaces and brightnesses available. The supplied color profiles were satisfactory, but you'll probably want to spring for Monaco EZ Color to get optimal results. (The company currently offers a 50-percent-off deal for Stylus Photo 1270 owners.)

Detecting differences between the printer's 720-dpi and 1,440-dpi output is generally pretty difficult. As with some past Epson models, the printer doesn't react well to switches from the higher resolution to the lower between print jobs. The result can be severe banding that appears in the output of a print job or two. In general the print quality is just better enough than that of the previous model -- the Stylus Photo 1200 -- to irritate those who own the older printer.

For the most part, the printer driver remains unchanged from previous versions. It gives you access to pretty much any setting you might want to adjust, including color spaces and ink mixes, but the switch for 1,440-dpi resolution irritatingly remains buried within the custom settings rather than on the top level with the presets.

Choices, Choices
The Stylus Photo 1270 can be found online for as low as $387. But if you don't need the support for 13-by-19-inch paper -- or don't have the budget for it -- consider the Epson Stylus Photo 870: It puts the same print-system (though with smaller ink cartridges) to work in a letter-sized package. The company also offers a version of the 870 -- the 875dc -- with a card reader that takes CompactFlash, SmartMedia, and Sony Memory Stick cards. The 875dc costs about $100 more than the 870.

This printer isn't a great choice for comping: It lacked an Adobe PressReady driver as we worked on this piece, though Adobe will likely follow with a driver soon; it's text quality isn't the best you'll find; and you're better off with the economy of a four-ink printer when comping in any case. If what you're after is a medium-format printer that delivers dazzling images, however, this is the sub-$1,000 printer to buy. Consider the estimated long life of the 1270's inks as a possible bonus you won't quite count on, and you should be thrilled with this printer rather than potentially disappointed.

Editor's Note: Wilhelm Imaging Research is now reporting that Epson 870/1270 output may experience a color shift within a matter of days when printed on Epson Premium Glossy Photo Paper, because the paper has an apparent high sensitivity to ozone and other airborne contaminants. Wilhelm recommends letting the glossy paper output dry for 24 hours under a normal piece of paper.

Read more by Lori Grunin.

1

What about the crippling orange color shift?

Alas, many users have found that 870/1270 prints do NOT have the advertised longevity. According to reports on the Epson website, on Henry Wilhelm's website, and on the Epson Leben list, many users are experiencing dramatic orange color shift -- in some cases, the shifts occur literally overnight!

One theory is that the 870/1270 ink and prmium glossy combination is sensitive to ozone. Whatever the cause, it is clear that the cyan ink can fade suddenly, resulting in a color shift to orange.

For now, the problem seems to be limited to the 870/1270 ink + premium glossy paper combination. I have, however, seen a few reports of orange shifts from users trying out other papers. Caveat emptor!

2

Orange Color Shift

I noticed the orange color shift in some of my prints form the 1270 on glossy premium paper that were exposed to the air. However prints from the same print run, which were under other prints, had not shifted color. I am following the recommendation to cover my prints for 24 hours with regular paper.

This little hassle to protect the print on glossy premium paper does not compare with the hassle of having my super B dye-sub prints treated to resist fading and other deterioration. I think anyone who has used chemicals to extend the life of inkjet or dye-sub prints will find this little glitch easy to work around.

I also trust Epson will correct this problem.

3

What's the deal with the 1270 ink set?

What I'd like to know, as an owner of the Photo 1200, is what's the big deal with the so called archival quality of the inks, that they only work with the 1270. Why can't Epson just squirt some of the new inks into cartridges designed for the 1200 and offer us the same potential archival qualities as 1270 owners? You mean to tell me that there is something special with the new inks that only the new printer can use?

So I'm up a creek as far as getting longer lasting prints because Epson blind sided some of us who bought the 1200.

What a joke.

Mark Harris
Mark Harris Photography

P.S. I hope it costs Epson a bundle both in $$s and bad public relations for the problem of the orange shift. Serves 'em right.

Note to HP, Canon, or any other printer vendor: Epson's just given you your opening to begin the process of taking away market share from them by offering a better product. Take advantage.

4

Who is the target user for this printer?

This article seemed like a great review of product I'm interested in purchasing, except for all the contradictory information! The sidebar states the target user for the Epson 1270 is artisit and designers, then, toward the end of the article, states that the printer is not so good for comping. Just what exactly would a designer do with the machine if it WEREN'T used for comping? Does the author mean proofing? My clients will put up with not-so-crisp type as long as I explain that I'm showing them a COMP, not an actual printed piece for proofing. I wish the author would have made it clear as to what was meant here, it could impact on my decision to purchase.

5

RE>comping

I think the author was stating that, as it shipped - without PostScript support - it's not really a printer designed to show clients comps (or proofs). You can use it for Photoshop and general tasks, and for some instances, you _can_ comp with it, but you'll really need some extra s/w - Epson's StylusRIP, PressReady, Birmy's PowerRIP or Infowave's StyleScript - if you want to use this as a comping device in the true sense of the word. (The fact that there aren't any of those RIPs available for this printer yet lessens its value right now, but that will disappear with their availability.)

Login

Login to post a comment. Not a member? Sign up here
Enter your CreativePro.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Forgot your password?