Out of Gamut: A Two-Pass Approach to Sharpening in Photoshop

Bruce Fraser's two-pass method of sharpening images helps discerning Photoshop users get it right.
Written by Bruce Fraser on March 13, 2001

Related Reading

Blurring the Lines
The next step is to apply a Gaussian Blur to the mask. This will accomplish two goals.

  • It will soften the edges around the edge mask, preventing sharp, unnatural-looking transitions between sharpened and unsharpened areas.

  • It will get rid of some of the noise that Find Edges picked up.

The radius setting depends primarily on the resolution of the image and secondarily on its content. High-resolution images typically require a higher-radius blur than low-resolution ones, and close subjects with soft detail, such as head shots, typically need a higher radius than high-frequency images with lots of fine detail. In this case, a Radius of around 2.8 pixels blurs out the noise while preserving the main edges, albeit in softened form, as shown in Figure 5.


Figure 5: Applying a blur prevents unnatural transitions and eliminates noise.

Next I'll invert the mask. This step is optional: I simply find it easier to see what's happening when I make the areas I want the mask to protect black and those I want it to affect white. Inverting the mask also means that you don't have to invert the selection after the mask is loaded. Choosing Invert from the Adjust submenu on the Image menu produces the result shown in Figure 6.


Figure 6: Applying a blur prevents unnatural transitions and eliminates noise.

The final step in creating the mask is to exaggerate the contrast of the mask, so that the edges we want to sharpen are really white and the noise we want to protect is really black. The Levels control offers an easy method for doing this. The trick here is to adjust the black and white input sliders in Levels so that the edges you want sharpened are pure white and the areas you want protected are solid black. You also want to leave a little gray in between, so that the transitions between sharpened and unsharpened areas are soft rather than sudden. The actual numbers will depend on the image, but typically you'll want to move the sliders quite a way in, so that a lot of pixels are forced to black and a good many are forced to white.

Figure 7 shows the Levels adjustment for our example, and its effect on the mask.


Figure 7: We used the Level adjustment to exaggerate contrast, to ensure the edges we want to sharpen are white and that noise is black.

Note that the mask still contains a fair number of gray pixels: Those areas will receive slight sharpening, and will prevent sharp transitions between the sharpened and unsharpened areas.

1

Small clarification

Nice article indeed.
Till recently I struggled trying to work out the best archival sharpening approach, but this technique opens my eyes.
I'm quite novice into Photoshop, so perhaps this is the reason of my confusion.
At the last step of first sharpning curve out of 2, you are applying the cretaed Edge mask to the image. However when I try to do that, there is no Load Selection available (on the original copy of the image) until I do Save Selection (choosing All option) in the Copy image containing the B/W mask)
Is that correct procedure ?
This step is missing in your instructions, probably due to the fact that is may seem obvious for more experienced users then me.

Thank in advance,
Alex Z

2

A Brilliant Tip!

Nice work, Brian! Until now, I was a practitioner of the blanket Unsharp Mask technique.

3

A Brilliant Tip!

Correction. "Nice work, Bruce!" Sorry, Bruce.

4

Great Article, suggestion

Thanks for the clear explanation!
In addition to Lee's suggestion about displaying results, another helpful graphic would show blown up details of the results of the different methods.
(Are we working you too hard?)
Thanks! -Alan

5

Good instructional information for the intermediate Photoshop us

Thanks to the author and Creative Pro. It is articles like this, that persuaded me some months ago to make Creative Pro my browser home page.

6

Look forward to your articles

I have learned much from reading your articles.
Your articles on sharpening are actually the best I have seen and now have used. I cannot wait until the next one!

7

Author use of wording is offensive

The author's choice of words is offensive to me - "Psorasis" is a uncontrollable skin disease- and has nothing to do with the picture quality he is trying to explain.
I am a Psorasis sufferer and hate the negative attitude people have towards it!!!
Choose your words more wisely as to not offend!

8

Very Helpful

Thanks for the great series on sharpening. I too used unsharpen for the entire image. It was always difficult to sharpen what needed it without magnifying noise.

9

Thankyou Bruce for this sort of insightful writing.

Bruce has basically given me a 'Shoe in' for using photoshop. It is thanks to Real World Photoshop that I have any hope of working in photoshop to achieve the 'fine print' maturity digitally that previously was for me the exclusive realm of the traditional darkroom. Many thanks....!

10

Good article, but JPEG is a poor choice for samples

Thanks for the very useful tips. However, I want to point out a problem with the way the sample images are published here -- you've used the JPEG format, which is lossy, even when used with a high quality setting. In several cases, the artifacts get in the way of seeing some of the subtle differences that you discuss. Some readers may not even realize the origin of the artifacts, and may misunderstand your points.

I would like to suggest that you use the PNG (portable network graphics) format, which supports full 24-bit color (unlike GIF, another poor choice for high fidelity in photos) and lossless compression (usually not as slim as JPEG, but reasonable, and leaves image unaltered). I believe that all modern versions of browsers include built-in support for PNG.

Thanks for the articles, and for entertaining my humble suggestion,

--Lee

Post a Comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p> <div> <br> <center> <img> <h2>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.